PuniCodex

PUNICODEX Scholarly Edition

Ninlil

Wind, Air · A living, university-curated reference. Verified scholars contribute; every edit is attributed, reviewed, and preserved.

Tier-2 Ninlil.com
01

Overview

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Concise scholarly summary of the figure, name, tradition, and significance.

Ninlil (ninlil) ​— Wind, Air ‌· Lady ‌of the wind ​— belongs to ​the Mesopotamian tradition, ​where it ​is catalogued under ​the domain "Wind, ‌Air". The name ​means "Lady ​of the wind"[1].

Ninlil is the ​Sumerian goddess ‌of the wind ​and the air, ‌the consort of ​Enlil and ​queen of the ​Mesopotamian pantheon. Her ​name, written 𒀭𒊩𒌆𒆤, ​simply means ‌'Lady of the ​Wind' — nin ‌('lady, queen') plus ​lil ('wind, ‌air'). Where Enlil ​commands the storm ‌and the decree ​of kingship, ‌Ninlil is the ​gentler sovereign of ​the moving air ‌itself: the ‌breath that fills ‌the lungs, the ​breeze that ​carries pollen, and ‌the unseen presence ​that links heaven ​and earth.

‌This temple honours ​Ninlil as both ​queen and mother. ‌She is ​the mother of ‌Nanna/Sîn the moon, ​of Nergal lord ​of the ​underworld, of Ninazu, ​and of Enbilulu ‌the canal inspector. ‌The myth ​Enlil and Ninlil ‌(ETCSL 1.2.1) weaves ​her story ​together with the ‌theological geography of ‌Mesopotamia: even the ‌queen of ‌the air must ​know the underworld, ‌because descent and ​generation are ​inseparable in the ​Sumerian cosmos.[2]

PuniCodex ‌restores the name ​as Ninlil ​and serves its ​temple at its ‌temple. The restoration ​needs no ​distinctive letters or ​diacritics its ASCII ‌form would lose, ​which places ‌the name in ​Tier 2. The ‌plain ASCII ​form ninlil survives ‌as a modern ‌convenience imposed by ​the early ​domain-name system; the ​restoration, not the ​fallback, is the ‌form the ‌project defends as ​philologically complete[3].

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
  2. Black & Green, Gods, Demons and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia.
  3. Jacobsen, The Treasures of Darkness.
02

The Name

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Etymology, ASCII constraint, Unicode restoration, name variations, tier classification.

The ​name ‌is attested ‌in ​Cuneiform ​as 𒀭𒊩𒌆𒆤. ​Etymologically ​it ​means "Lady ‌of ​the ​wind"[1].

The ‌ASCII ​form ‌ninlil survives ​only ‌because ​the early ​domain-name ​system ​could not ​carry ‌diacritics; ​it is ‌a ​technological ‌compromise, not ​an ‌ancient ​spelling. The ‌Unicode ​restoration ​Ninlil recovers ‌the ‌full ‌diacritic detail ​of ​the ‌scholarly transliteration ​directly ​in ‌the address ​bar. ​The ‌restoration needs ​no ‌distinctive ​letters or ​diacritics ​its ​ASCII form ‌would ‌lose, ​which places ‌the ​name ​in Tier ‌2.

‌The ‌letter-by-letter transformation ‌runs:

​- ‌n → ​N ​— ​Same, capitalized
‌- ​i ​→ i ​— ‌Same
​- n ​→ ​n ‌— Same
​- ‌l ​→ l ‌— ​Same
‌- i ‌→ ​i ​— Same
​- ​l ‌→ l ‌— ​Same

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
03

Pronunciation

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

IPA reconstruction, phoneme breakdown, approximation, kin forms.

The reconstructed ​pronunciation of ‌the name is ‌/nɪnˈlɪl/ — ​Sumerian Reconstruction.[1]

Phoneme ​by phoneme:

​- Nin- — ​Voiceless alveolar ​stop [n] plus ‌close front ​vowel [ɪ] — ​the Sumerian ‌word for 'lady, ​queen,' marking ‌her rank in ​the pantheon.
‌- -lil — ​Lateral approximant ​[l] repeated around ​a short ​[ɪ] — the ​Sumerian word ‌for 'wind' or ​'air,' the ‌element she embodies ​and governs.

‌For the modern ​speaker, the ‌closest approximation is: ​'nin-LIL' — ‌stress the second ​syllable and ​let the name ‌end with ‌a light, breathy ‌lilt, like ​wind passing through ​reeds.

Kindred ‌and historical forms ​of the ​name:

  • Sumerian ‌— 𒀭𒊩𒌆𒆤 ​(dnin-lil₂), 'lady of ​the wind/air' ‌— queen of ​the Sumerian ‌gods and consort ​of Enlil

​- Akkadian — ​Mullil / ​Mullissu, the Akkadian ‌rendering of ‌Ninlil, later identified ​with the ‌consort of Aššur
​- Cuneiform ​— 𒀭𒊩𒌆𒆤, written ‌with the ‌divine determinative 𒀭 ‌(dingir) prefixed ‌to the name

​Ninlil is ‌Tier 2: the ​canonical Unicode ​restoration is identical ​to the ‌ASCII form, with ​no distinctive ​diacritic or non-ASCII ​letter preserved. ‌The name is ​the same ​in both forms; ​what the ‌temple protects is ​not a ‌phonological mark but ​the proper-name ‌capitalization and the ​scholarly framing ‌of a Sumerian ‌theonym. Standard ​Assyriology writes Ninlil; ​PuniCodex presents ​the plain form ​as a ‌baseline restoration of ‌a Mesopotamian ​divine name.

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
04

Original Script & Provenance

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Original writing system, transliteration steps, uncertainty markers, font/display notes.

The ​name ‌is ‌​preserved ​in ​Cuneiform ​as ​‌𒀭𒊩𒌆𒆤 ​— ​Sumero-Akkadian ‌cuneiform, ​attested ‌​Sumerian ‌/ ​Old ​Babylonian ​​– ​Neo-Assyrian, ‌c. ​2600–600 ‌BCE, ​‌in ​Mesopotamia. ‌The ​script ‌​is ​written ‌left-to-right ‌/ ‌top-to-bottom.[1]

​​The ‌scholarly ​transliteration ​is ‌​Ninlil ​(Sumerian ‌logogram ​+ ‌Akkadian ​​scholarly), ​giving ​the ‌normalized ‌​reading ‌/ˈnin.lil/.

​The ​rendering ‌proceeds ‌‌step ‌by ​step:

‌- ​​Sumerogram ​NIN.LÍL ‌(𒊩𒌆𒆤), ​'lady ​of ​‌the ​wind'
​- ​Prefixed ‌​with ‌divine ​determinative ‌𒀭
​- ‌‌Consort ​of ​Enlil ​and ​‌mother ‌of ​Nanna/Sîn

Sources

  1. Black & Green, Gods, Demons and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia.
  2. CAD, Ninlil.
  3. Chicago Assyrian Dictionary (CAD).
  4. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature (ETCSL).
05

Domains & Attributes

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Sphere of influence, titles, epithets, domain cards.

Ninlil is ​the Sumerian ‌goddess of the ‌wind and ​the air, the ​consort of ​Enlil and queen ​of the ​Mesopotamian pantheon. Her ‌name, written ​𒀭𒊩𒌆𒆤, simply means ​'Lady of the ‌Wind' — ​nin ('lady, queen') ‌plus lil ​('wind, air'). Where ‌Enlil commands ​the storm and ​the decree ​of kingship, Ninlil ​is the ​gentler sovereign of ‌the moving ​air itself: the ‌breath that ​fills the lungs, ‌the breeze ​that carries pollen, ‌and the ​unseen presence that ‌links heaven ​and earth.

This ​temple honours ‌Ninlil as both ‌queen and mother. ‌She is ​the mother of ​Nanna/Sîn the ‌moon, of Nergal ​lord of ​the underworld, of ‌Ninazu, and ​of Enbilulu the ​canal inspector. ‌The myth Enlil ​and Ninlil ‌(ETCSL 1.2.1) weaves ​her story ​together with the ​theological geography ​of Mesopotamia: even ‌the queen ‌of the air ​must know ‌the underworld, because ​descent and generation ​are inseparable ‌in the Sumerian ‌cosmos.[1]

‌The Wind

The ‌moving air ​itself — breath, ‌breeze, and ​the life-giving currents ​that cross ​the Mesopotamian plain.

‌### Queenship

​Consort of Enlil ​and queen ​of the gods; ‌the divine ​matriarch from whom ​lunar and ​netherworld powers descend.

‌### The ​Crescent Moon

Mother ‌of Nanna/Sîn; ​the lunar crescent ‌is her descendant's ​sign, linking ‌wind-queen to night-light.

‌### Descent ​and Return

The ​mythic journey ​into the underworld ​that generates ‌new gods and ‌new seasons ​of life.

Sources

  1. Black & Green, Gods, Demons and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia.
06

Symbols

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Iconography, attributes, and their meanings.

The ​iconography ‌associated ‌with Ninlil ​concentrates ​in ​a ​small ​set ‌of recurring ​attributes, ​each ‌a ​compressed ‌statement ​about the ‌name:[1]

​- ​Wind ​and ​breath ​— The ‌invisible ​air ‌that ​sustains ‌life and ​carries ‌the ​voice ‌of ​command
​- Crescent ‌moon ‌— ‌The ​sign ​of ‌her son ​Nanna/Sîn, ​the ‌moon ​god
​- ‌Gate and ​canal ‌— ​The ​liminal ​places ​where Ninlil ‌meets ‌Enlil ​in ‌the ​myth ​of their ‌union
‌- ‌Grain ‌and ​reed ‌— The ​crops ​that ​bend ‌in ​the wind ​and ​depend ‌on ​air-borne ​pollination
​- Horned ‌crown ​— ‌The ​crown ‌of ​divine queenship ‌worn ‌by ​the ​chief ​consort ​of the ‌king ‌of ​gods

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
07

Mythology

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Core myths, primary narratives, and textual evidence.

Ninlil's myths are ​stories of boundary-crossing: the ‌wind that moves between worlds, ‌the queen who descends ​into darkness, and the ​mother whose children personify moon, ​death, water, and order. ​She is not a passive ​consort; she is the ‌necessary counterpart without whom ​Enlil's kingship would be incomplete.[1]

​### Enlil and Ninlil ‌(The Sacred Marriage)

The Sumerian ​poem Enlil and Ninlil ‌(ETCSL 1.2.1) tells how ​the young god Enlil saw ‌Ninlil by the canal ​at Nippur and desired her. ​After he impregnated her, ​the assembled gods banished ​him from the city for ​his offence. Ninlil followed ‌him into exile. In the ​underworld Enlil met her ‌three times in disguise — ​as the gatekeeper, the ‌river-man, and the ferryman ​— and each union produced ‌a child: Nergal, Ninazu, ​and Enbilulu. The story explains ‌the origin of three ​underworld or chthonic deities ​and makes theological sense of ‌descent: even the king ‌and queen of the air ‌must generate the powers ​of the depths.[2]

​Mother of the Moon (Maternity)

‌Ninlil is the mother ​of Nanna/Sîn, the moon god, ​and in some traditions ‌also of Inanna/Ištar and ​Utu/Shamash. The moon's regular cycle ​becomes an extension of ‌the air-queen's generative power: what ​moves unseen by day ‌shines by night. Royal hymns ​from Ur and Nippur ​invoke Ninlil alongside Enlil ​as the divine parents who ​legitimate the king and ‌protect the city.

Ninlil ‌in the Netherworld (Descent)

​In the myth The ‌Descent of Enlil and related ​hymnic traditions, Ninlil accompanies ​or follows Enlil into the ‌netherworld. Her presence there ‌is not punishment but ‌cosmic necessity: the queen of ‌the upper air must ​also know the lower world, ‌so that the breath ​of life and the ​breath of the dead remain ​in relation. This descent ‌mirrors the better-known descent of ​Inanna, but it is ​told through the lens of ​divine sovereignty rather than ‌individual transformation.

The ​Temples of Ninlil (Cult)

Ninlil's ​principal cult centre was ​at Nippur, where she shared ‌the great sanctuary complex ​with Enlil. Sumerian temple ‌hymns praise her house and ​link her authority to ‌the Ekur, the 'Mountain House' ​of Enlil. In later ‌Assyrian religion she was ‌equated with Mullissu, the consort ​of Aššur, and her ​cult travelled with Assyrian kingship ​to cities such as ​Nineveh and Assur. Her ‌worship thus spans Sumer, Babylonia, ‌and Assyria across more ​than two millennia.

Sources

  1. Black & Green, Gods, Demons and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia.
  2. Jacobsen, The Treasures of Darkness.
08

Syncretism & Reception

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Cross-cultural identification, later adaptations, and interpretatio.

The ​Unicode form ‌Ninlil ‌is ​a baseline ​restoration: ​standard Assyriology ​writes ​the ‌name without ​diacritics, ​and the ‌canonical ​PuniCodex ‌form preserves ​that ‌plain spelling ​while ​asserting ​proper-name status. ​In ​Akkadian and ‌Assyrian ​sources ‌Ninlil was ​identified ‌with Mullissu ​(also ‌spelled ​Mulliltu), the ‌consort ​of the ​national ‌god ‌Aššur. In ‌Hittite ​and Hurrian ​milieus ‌her ​functions were ​partly ‌absorbed by ​the ​great ‌goddess Hepat ​and ‌by ​local consort ​deities. ​Greek and ​Roman ‌writers ‌had no ​direct ‌equivalent for ​Ninlil, ​though ‌her rank ‌as ‌queen of ‌the ​gods ‌and her ​association ​with air ​invite ‌loose ​comparison with ​Hera ​or Juno; ‌the ​comparison, ​however, is ​typological ‌rather than ​historical.[1]

‌Within ​the Mesopotamian ‌tradition, ​closely related ‌names ‌in ​the corpus ​include ​Adad, Anû, ​Apsû, ‌Aššur, ‌Dumuzid, and ​Ēa.

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
09

Cultural Legacy

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Modern influence, literature, art, popular culture, and contemporary practice.

Ninlil ​survives ‌in Assyriological ‌scholarship ​and ​in the ​modern ​recovery ​of ‌Sumerian religion ​through ​ETCSL ‌and the ​great ‌lexical ​projects ‌of the ​twentieth ​and ​twenty-first centuries. ​She ​is ‌less ​famous in ‌popular ​culture ‌than her ​daughter ‌Ištar ​or ‌her consort ​Enlil, ​yet ‌her role ‌as ‌wind-queen ​and ​mother of ‌lunar ​and ​netherworld powers ‌makes ​her ​essential ‌to any ​coherent ‌picture ​of ​the Mesopotamian ​pantheon. ​The ‌name Ninlil ‌is ​sometimes ‌adopted ​by fantasy ​settings ‌and ‌neopagan circles ‌as ‌an ​emblem ‌of air, ​sovereignty, ​and ​the unseen. ‌PuniCodex ​presents ​the ​plain ASCII ‌form ​not ​as a ​deficiency ‌but ​as ‌a philologically ​honest ‌baseline: ​there is ‌no ‌recovered ​diacritic ​to restore, ​only ​the ‌name itself ‌to ​remember.[1]

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
10

Archaeology & Material Evidence

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Sites, inscriptions, artifacts, and physical attestations.

Cuneiform ​tablets ‌from ‌​Nippur, ​Ur, ​and ​Assur ​attest ‌​Ninlil's ​cult ‌from ​the ‌Early ​Dynastic ‌​period ​into ​the ​first ​millennium ‌​BCE. ‌The ​Ekur ‌sanctuary ​at ‌​Nippur, ‌excavated ​by ​the ‌University ‌of ‌​Pennsylvania ​and ‌Iraqi ​teams, ​preserves ‌​the ​architectural ‌setting ​of ‌her ​​worship ​alongside ​Enlil. ‌Assyrian ‌royal ​‌inscriptions ​from ​Nineveh ‌and ‌Assur ‌name ‌​Mullissu/Ninlil ‌as ​the ​divine ​consort ‌​who ​legitimises ​the ‌king, ​while ​​cylinder ‌seals ​and ‌votive ​objects ‌depict ​‌her ‌wearing ​the ​horned ​crown ​‌of ‌divine ​queenship.[1]

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
11

Scholarly Sources

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Cited primary and secondary sources with full bibliographic metadata.

The ​account ‌of ‌Ninlil given ​in ​this ​edition ​rests ​on ‌the ​witnesses and ​reference ‌works ​listed ‌below. ​Lexica ‌and ​etymological dictionaries ​secure ​the ​form ​and ‌meaning ​of ‌the name; ​the ‌literary ​and ‌religious ​texts ‌supply the ​narrative ​evidence.

‌- ‌[1] ‌Electronic ​Text ​Corpus of ‌Sumerian ​Literature, ​Oxford ‌Oriental ​Institute, ​1998. ‌Full text
​- ‌[2] ​Black ​& ​Green, ​Gods, ‌Demons and ‌Symbols ​of ‌Ancient ​Mesopotamia.
​- ‌[3] ‌Jacobsen, The ‌Treasures ‌of ​Darkness.
‌- ​[4] ​Kramer, Sumerian ​Literary ‌Texts ​from ​Nippur.
​- ‌[5] ​George, House ​Most ​High: ‌The ​Temples ‌of ​Ancient ‌Mesopotamia.

  • [6]Enlil ‌and ​Ninlil ​(ETCSL ​1.2.1).

​- [7] ‌Sumerian ‌Temple ​Hymns.

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
  2. Black & Green, Gods, Demons and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia.
  3. Jacobsen, The Treasures of Darkness.
  4. Kramer, Sumerian Literary Texts from Nippur.
  5. George, House Most High: The Temples of Ancient Mesopotamia.
  6. Enlil and Ninlil (ETCSL 1.2.1).
  7. Sumerian Temple Hymns.
12

Cuneiform Sources

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Ninlil’s ​name ‌and ‌cult ​are ​attested ​across ​three ​millennia ‌of ​cuneiform ​‌writing. ​The ‌Sumerian ​poem ‌Enlil ​and ​Ninlil ​(ETCSL ​1.2.1) ​supplies ‌the ​fullest ‌narrative, ​recounting ‌her ​unions ‌that ​conceive ‌Nanna/Sîn, ​Nergal, ​Ninazu ‌‌and ‌Enbilulu ​within ​the ‌theological ​geography ​of ‌Nippur ​and ​the ‌netherworld. ​Royal ‌inscriptions ​and ​temple ​hymns ​from ‌Ur ‌and ​Assur ‌invoke ​​her ‌as ‌dnin-lil₂ ‌(𒀭𒊩𒌆𒆤), ‌usually ​paired ‌with ​Enlil, ​while ​administrative ‌tablets ​record ​regular ​offerings ‌at ​her ​shrines. ​God ‌lists ​such ‌as ​‌An ​= ‌Anum ‌fix ​her ​rank ​in ​the ‌canonical ‌Mesopotamian ​pantheon.[1][2][3]

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
  2. Black, Jeremy & Green, Anthony. Gods, Demons and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia. British Museum Press, 1992.
  3. George, Andrew R. House Most High: The Temples of Ancient Mesopotamia. Eisenbrauns, 1993.
13

Enūma Eliš

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

The ​late ‌Babylonian ‌Enūma ​Eliš ​​celebrates ​Marduk’s ​defeat ‌of ​Tiamat, ​yet ‌it ​rests ‌on ​an ‌​older ​theological ​architecture ​in ​which ‌Enlil, ​Ninlil’s ‌consort, ​embodies ‌supreme ​‌authority. ​By ‌the ​first ​millennium ‌BCE ‌Ninlil ‌had ​been ​identified ‌​with ​Mullissu, ‌the ​Assyrian ​consort ‌of ​Aššur, ‌and ​her ​lineage ​​was ‌woven ‌into ​the ‌imperial ​pantheon ​the ‌epic ‌proclaims. ‌Thus ‌​the ‌poem ​does ​not ​stage ‌Ninlil ​directly; ​it ​testifies ‌to ​​the ​sovereignty ‌she ​anchors—air, ‌queenship ​and ‌the ​transmission ‌of ‌kingship ​​from ​Sumer ​through ‌Babylon ‌to ​Assyria.[1][2]

Sources

  1. Foster, Benjamin R. Before the Muses: An Anthology of Akkadian Literature. CDL Press, 2005.
  2. Dalley, Stephanie. Myths from Mesopotamia: Creation, the Flood, Gilgamesh, and Others. Oxford University Press, 2000.
14

Atra-Ḫasīs

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

In ​the ‌‌Akkadian ​Atra-Ḫasīs ​​epic, ​Enlil’s ​‌anger ​unleashes ​‌the ​flood ‌that ​‌nearly ​extinguishes ​​humankind. ​Ninlil’s ​‌domain—the ​air, ‌​wind ‌and ​breath ‌​of ‌life—is ​​precisely ‌the ‌‌element ​the ​‌deluge ​violates. ​When ‌​the ​gods ‌​settle ‌for ​​a ​regulated ​human ‌‌population ​and ‌​institutions ​that ‌‌channel ‌mortality, ‌​they ‌restore ​the ​​cosmic ‌conditions ​​Ninlil ​governs. ‌​Her ​queenship ​‌of ​the ‌air ​‌therefore ​underwrites ‌‌the ​postdiluvian ​​order ​the ‌‌narrative ​establishes.[1][2]

Sources

  1. Foster, Benjamin R. Before the Muses: An Anthology of Akkadian Literature. CDL Press, 2005.
  2. Dalley, Stephanie. Myths from Mesopotamia: Creation, the Flood, Gilgamesh, and Others. Oxford University Press, 2000.
  3. Jacobsen, Thorkild. The Treasures of Darkness: A History of Mesopotamian Religion. Yale University Press, 1976.
15

Meditation & Reflection

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Contemplative or interpretive essay on the figure's enduring meaning.

Air ​is the ‌most ‌taken-for-granted element. ​We do ​not ​see it ​until ​it moves, ‌do not ​value ​it until ‌it ​fails. Ninlil ‌is the ​goddess ‌of that ​taken-for-grantedness ​made sacred: ​the breath ​in ​the body, ‌the ​wind in ‌the ​grain, the ‌medium that ​carries ‌both speech ​and ‌storm. Her ​marriage to ​Enlil ‌is the ‌marriage ‌of power ​to atmosphere: ​he ‌decrees, she ​enables; ​he commands, ‌she circulates.

​To ​restore the ‌name ​Ninlil is ‌therefore ​to restore ​attention. There ​is ​no macron ‌or ‌circumflex to ​argue over ‌here; ​the philological ​work ‌is simply ‌to keep ‌the ‌name from ​flattening ‌into noise. ​In a ​world ​of brandable ‌deities, ​a Tier-2 ​name ​is easily ‌dismissed. But ​Ninlil ​reminds us ​that ‌not every ​god needs ‌a ​diacritic to ‌matter. ​Some names ‌carry their ‌distinction ​in the ​thing ​they name: ​the wind ‌itself, ‌invisible and ​everywhere.[1]

Sources

  1. Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature, Oxford Oriental Institute, 1998.
16

Edit History

Live Record

Immutable revision timeline and attribution.

Every approved change will appear here with a timestamp, diff, and credit to the contributing university and student.

17

Attribution

Live Record

Universities and students credited for contributions.

Verified universities and their students will be credited here as the Scholarly Edition grows.