PuniCodex

PUNICODEX Scholarly Edition

Ọbalúayé

Disease, Healing, Earth · A living, university-curated reference. Verified scholars contribute; every edit is attributed, reviewed, and preserved.

Preserves stress Ọbalúayé.com
01

Overview

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Concise scholarly summary of the figure, name, tradition, and significance.

Ọbalúayé (babaluaye) ​— Disease, ‌Healing, Earth ‌· Father ​of the ​world — ​belongs to the ​Yoruba tradition, ​where it ‌is catalogued ​under the ​domain "Disease, ‌Healing, Earth". ​The name means ‌"Father of ​the world"[1].

‌Ọbalúayé is ​the orixá ​who both ​strikes and heals. ​He governs ​infectious disease ‌— especially ​smallpox — ‌and the ​earth that receives ‌the body ​after death. ‌His name ​means 'king ‌whose scourge ​is the world,' ​and his ‌presence is ‌feared because ‌illness arrives ​without warning ​and leaves ‌without explanation. Yet ​he is ​also the ‌one who ​can lift ​what he ‌has sent, and ​his devotees ‌often become ​the most ​skilled healers.

​In the ​diaspora he appears ‌as an ‌old man ​on crutches, ‌wrapped in ​burlap, accompanied ​by dogs. ‌He is poverty, ‌affliction, and ‌survival at ‌once.[2]

PuniCodex ​restores the ‌name as ​Ọbalúayé and serves ​its temple ​at ọbalúayé.com. ‌The original ​preserves one ​prosodic feature ​— stress or ‌vowel length ​— a ​distinctive mark ​the ASCII ‌form loses. ​The plain ASCII ‌form babaluaye ​survives as ‌a modern ​convenience imposed ‌by the ‌early domain-name ​system; the restoration, ​not the ​fallback, is ​the form ‌the project ‌defends as ​philologically complete[3].

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
  2. Bascom, Ifa Divination.
  3. Mason, Four New World Yoruba Rituals.
02

The Name

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Etymology, transliteration, canonical spelling, name variations, and evidence preservation.

No ​indigenous written ‌attestation survives ‌for this ​name; Ọbalúayé ​is ​a scholarly ​transliteration of ​the reconstructed ‌spoken form. ​Etymologically the ​name ‌means "Father ​of the ‌world"[1].

The ​ASCII form ‌babaluaye ​survives only ​because the ​early domain-name ​system could ​not carry ‌diacritics; ​it is ‌a technological ​compromise, not ‌an ancient ​spelling. ‌The Unicode ​restoration Ọbalúayé ‌recovers the ​stress accent ​of the ‌original ‌directly in ‌the address ​bar. The ​original preserves ‌one ​prosodic feature ​— stress ‌or vowel ​length — ​a distinctive ‌mark ​the ASCII ‌form loses.

​The letter-by-letter ​transformation runs:

  • ​b ​→ Ọ ‌— Initial ‌b becomes ​Ọ
  • a ‌→ b ​— ​Shifted consonant
  • ‌b → ‌a — ‌Shifted vowel
  • ‌a ​→ l ‌— Shifted ​consonant
  • l ​→ ú ​— Acute ‌on ​u
  • u ​→ a ​— Shifted ‌vowel
  • a ​→ ​y — ​Shifted consonant
  • ‌y → ​é — ‌Acute on ​e
  • ‌e → ​— — ‌Not written

‌The project ​holds ​the domain ​ọbalúayé.com (xn--balay-fsa0j098y.com) ​as the ‌canonical home ‌of this ​name[2].

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
  2. Bascom, Ifa Divination.
03

Pronunciation

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

IPA reconstruction, phoneme breakdown, approximation, kin forms.

The reconstructed ​pronunciation of ‌the name ‌is /ɔ̀.bà.lú.à.jé/ ​— Yoruba Reconstruction.[1]

​Phoneme by ​phoneme:

  • Ọ- ​— Open-mid back ​rounded vowel ‌[ɔ] with ​low tone, ​written with a ‌dot below.
  • ​-bà- — ‌Voiced bilabial stop ​[b] followed ‌by open ​[a] with ​low tone.
  • -lú- ​— Voiced ​alveolar lateral ​approximant [l] followed ‌by close ​back rounded ‌vowel [u] ​with high tone.
  • ‌-à- — ​Open central ‌vowel [a] with ​low tone.
  • ‌-yé — ​Palatal approximant ​[j] followed by ‌close-mid front ‌vowel [e] ‌with high tone; ​the name ​means 'father ‌whose scourge ​is the world'.

​For the ‌modern speaker, ​the closest approximation ​is: aw-bah-loo-ah-YEH ‌— low ​on the ‌first three syllables, ​then high ​on 'YEH'.

​Kindred and historical ​forms of ‌the name:

  • ‌Yoruba — ​Ọbalúayé, the orixá ‌of disease, ​healing, and ​the earth.
  • Brazilian ‌Candomblé — ‌Obaluaiê, the ‌orixá of ‌smallpox and its ​cure, syncretised ‌with Saint ​Lazarus and Saint ​Roch.
  • Cuban ​Santería — ‌Babalú Ayé, ​the old man ​on crutches ​who both ‌inflicts and removes ​sickness.

Ọbalúayé ​preserves both ​features: the ‌acute accents on ​ú and ‌é preserve ​high tones — ‌distinctive features ​the ASCII ‌form loses ‌— while grave ​accents would ​mark low ​tones. The dot ​below ọ ‌distinguishes open ‌[ɔ] from ​close [o].

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
04

Original Script & Provenance

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Original writing system, transliteration steps, uncertainty markers, font/display notes.

The ​Yoruba language ‌had no ‌phonetic writing ​system ​before the ​nineteenth century; ​the names ​of ‌its powers, ​including Ọbalúayé ​and ‌his older, ​more dangerous ‌praise names, ​were ‌transmitted orally ​in the ​Ifá corpus, ​in ​oríkì praise ​poetry, and ‌in the ​liturgy ‌of the ​smallpox cult.[1] ‌The first ​printed ‌records of ​the language ‌are mission ​vocabularies: ​John Raban's ‌A Vocabulary ‌of ‌the Eyo ​or Aku ​(1830–1832), then ‌Samuel ​Ajayi Crowther's ​A Vocabulary ‌of the ​Yoruba ​Language (1843) ‌and his ​Grammar and ‌Vocabulary ​of the ​Yoruba Language ​(1852).[2]

Modern ​standard ‌Yoruba orthography, ‌codified from ​Ayo Bamgbose's ‌1965 ​study and ​the 1966 ‌Yoruba ‌Orthography Committee, ‌writes the ‌Latin alphabet ​with ‌sub-dots (ẹ, ​ọ, ṣ) ​and tone ​marks; ‌the mid ​tone goes ​unmarked.[3] Ọbalúayé ​follows ‌this convention ​— ọ ​marks the ​open ‌vowel [ɔ], ​ú and ‌é carry ​high ‌tones — ​while diaspora ‌spellings ‌(Obaluaiê, Babalú ​Ayé, Omolu) ​record the ​same ​spoken name ‌through Portuguese ‌and Spanish ​orthographies.

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief, Longmans, 1962. ↗
  2. Crowther, A Grammar and Vocabulary of the Yoruba Language, Seeleys, 1852. ↗
  3. Abraham, Dictionary of Modern Yoruba, University of London Press, 1958. ↗
05

Domains & Attributes

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Sphere of influence, titles, epithets, domain cards.

Ọbalúayé ​is the ‌orixá who ‌both strikes ​and ​heals. He ​governs infectious ​disease — ​especially ‌smallpox — ​and the ​earth that ‌receives the ​body ‌after death. ​His name ‌means 'king ​whose ​scourge is ​the world,' ​and his ​presence ‌is feared ​because illness ‌arrives without ​warning ‌and leaves ​without explanation. ‌Yet he ​is ‌also the ​one who ​can lift ‌what he ‌has ‌sent, and ​his devotees ​often become ‌the ​most skilled ​healers.

In ‌the diaspora ​he ​appears as ‌an old ​man on ‌crutches, ​wrapped in ​burlap, accompanied ​by dogs. ​He ‌is poverty, ‌affliction, and ​survival at ‌once.[1]

​Disease and ​Pestilence

Smallpox, ‌leprosy, and ‌epidemic illness ‌walk ‌in his ​shadow.

Healing

‌The same ​hand ​that sends ​illness can ‌remove it; ​his ​priests are ​herbalists and ‌cleaners.

Earth ​and ​the Grave

​He rules ‌the soil ​that ‌receives the ​dead and ‌the bacteria ​that break ‌the ‌body down.

​Survival

Those ​who survive ​his ​illness often ‌become his ‌children for ​life.

Sources

  1. Bascom, Ifa Divination.
06

Symbols

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Iconography, attributes, and their meanings.

The ​iconography associated ‌with Ọbalúayé ‌concentrates ​in a ​small set ​of recurring ​attributes, ​each a ‌compressed statement ​about ​the name:[1]

  • ‌Crutches — ​His ‌diaspora attribute, ​marking lameness ‌and ​the limit ​of the ​human body.
  • ​Burlap ​or sackcloth ‌— Poverty, ​humility, ‌and the ​rough texture ‌of ​illness and ‌recovery; in ​ritual ‌it also ​veils the ​marked body ‌from ‌view.
  • Two ‌dogs — ​His ​messengers and ‌guardians at ​the ​boundary of ‌sickness and ​health.
  • ​Earth-coloured beads ‌— Brown, ​black, and ‌purple ​beads that ​link him ​to ​soil and ‌burial.

In ‌Candomblé ​his ritual ‌whisk, the ​xaxará, ​is woven ‌from palm ‌ribs and ‌swept ‌over the ​body and ‌the ​temple to ​lift illness ​away, ‌and his ​ceremonies are ​conducted ​in lowered ‌light, his ​power kept ​partially ​veiled.[2] The ‌attributes converge ​on ‌a single ​lesson: affliction ‌concealed ​is affliction ‌ungoverned, and ‌the ​cult makes ​the marks ​of disease ​visible ‌in order ‌to master ​them.[1]

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
  2. Verger, Notes sur le Culte des Orisa et Vodun, IFAN, Dakar, 1957.
07

Mythology

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Core myths, primary narratives, and textual evidence.

Ọbalúayé's mythology ​is less ‌a set ‌of heroic adventures ​than a ​meditation on illness, ​marginality, and ​the earth's ​power to break ‌and remake ​the body.[1]

The ​Scourge of ‌the World ​(Origin)

Ọbalúayé is ‌called 'Father ​of the ‌World' not because ​he nurtures ​it but because ​his diseases ​touch everyone, ​high and low. ‌In some ​accounts he was ‌once a ​proud king ‌who was brought ​low by ‌sickness and learned ​compassion only ‌after he ​himself had suffered. ​His myth ‌teaches that ‌the healer must ‌know the ​body from the ​inside of ‌affliction.[2]

The ​Dog and the ​Herb (Healing)

‌Stories of Ọbalúayé ​often involve ​a dog ‌who leads a ​sufferer to ‌a healing ​herb or a ​stream. The ​dog is his ​messenger, moving ‌between the ‌realm of disease ​and the ‌realm of cure. ​The myth ​encodes the ‌practical work of ‌finding medicine: ‌one must ‌follow signs that ​do not ‌speak in human ​language.

Babalú ​Ayé at ​the Crossroads (Diaspora)

‌In Cuban ​Santería, Babalú Ayé ​is depicted ​as an ‌old beggar at ​the crossroads, ​leaning on crutches, ​accompanied by ‌dogs. He ​receives offerings of ‌roasted corn, ​tobacco, and ‌dry wine. The ​image preserves ‌the Yoruba sense ‌that illness ​can reduce ​anyone to dependence ​— and ​that dependence, rightly ‌borne, becomes ‌a form ​of holiness.

Sources

  1. Bascom, Ifa Divination.
  2. Mason, Four New World Yoruba Rituals.
08

Syncretism & Reception

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Cross-cultural identification, later adaptations, and interpretatio.

In ​Brazilian ‌Candomblé, Ọbalúayé ‌became ​Obaluaiê, ​syncretised ​with Saint ​Lazarus ​(the ‌beggar ​covered in ​sores) ‌and ​Saint ‌Roch (who ​shows ‌the ​plague ​sore on ​his ​thigh). ​In ‌Cuban Santería ​he ‌is ​Babalú ‌Ayé, often ​identified ‌with ​Saint ‌Lazarus. The ​Catholic ​saints ‌of ‌leprosy and ‌plague ​mapped ​neatly ‌onto the ​Yoruba ​deity ‌of ​epidemic disease, ​and ‌the ​image ‌of the ​old ​man ​on ​crutches became ‌a ‌shared ​icon ‌across the ​Atlantic.[1]

​Kindred ‌figures ‌in the ‌PuniCodex ‌cross-tradition ​index ‌include Ašeratu ​(sea ​/ ​water), ‌Bꜣstt (earth ​/ ​mother ​/ ‌fertility), Cōātlīcue ​(earth ​/ ​mother ‌/ fertility), ​Dāgan ‌(earth ​/ ‌mother / ​fertility), ‌Dēmētēr ‌(earth ​/ mother ​/ ​fertility), ​and ‌Ēa (sea ‌/ ​water).

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
09

Cultural Legacy

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Modern influence, literature, art, popular culture, and contemporary practice.

Ọbalúayé's ​legacy is ‌the theology ‌of illness. ​In ​Yoruba and ​Afro-Atlantic thought, ​sickness ​is not ‌mere biological ​accident; it ​is ‌a message, ​a punishment, ‌or a ​calling.[1] ‌When the ​World Health ​Organization ​declared smallpox ​eradicated in ​1980, his ‌oldest ​enemy vanished ‌from the ​earth, yet ‌the ​cult did ‌not vanish ​with ‌it: devotion ​in Cuba ​and Brazil ‌turned ‌toward the ‌epidemics that ​remained, and ​during ‌the AIDS ​crisis the ​orisha ‌of epidemic ​and cure ​gathered a ‌new ​generation of ‌devotees.[2]

His ​name also ​travelled ​far beyond ​the temple. ‌Margarita ‌Lecuona's Afro-Cuban ​song 'Babalú' ‌(1939), popularised ​internationally ​by Desi ‌Arnaz, carried ‌the orisha's ‌name ‌into global ​popular culture ‌— ​a secular ​afterlife detached ​from the ‌theology ​but proof ​of the ​diaspora's reach.[3] ‌In ​an age ​of global ​pandemics ‌his mythology ​retains its ‌force: the ​earth ‌can still ​send plagues, ‌and the ‌boundary ​between health ​and sickness ​remains ​thinner than ‌modern medicine ‌likes to ​admit.[1]

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
  2. Murphy, Santería: An African Religion in America, Beacon Press, 1988. ↗
  3. Lecuona, Margarita, 'Babalú' (Afro-Cuban song), 1939.
10

Archaeology & Material Evidence

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Sites, inscriptions, artifacts, and physical attestations.

No ​monumental cult ‌of ‌Ọbalúayé ​is attested, ​and ​the ​explanation is ​partly ‌historical: ​smallpox cults ​in ‌Yorubaland ​were feared ‌institutions, ​and ‌in the ​colonial ​period the ​Ṣọ̀pọ̀nná ​cult ​was suppressed ‌in ​several ‌districts on ​the ‌charge ​that its ‌priests ​spread ‌the very ​infection ​they ‌claimed to ‌control.[1][2] ‌What survives ​is ​ethnographic ‌rather than ​archaeological ​— ‌shrine vessels, ​earth-toned ​bead ‌strands, and ​the ‌brooms ​and staffs ​of ​the ​healing cult ‌preserved ‌in ​ethnographic collections.[1]

‌The ​fuller material ​record ‌lies ‌in the ‌diaspora: ‌Candomblé ​houses preserve ‌the ​xaxará ​whisk, the ​burlap ‌garment, ​and the ​sequestered ​shrine ‌of Obaluaiê, ​while ​Cuban devotion ​centres ‌on ​the pilgrimage ‌shrine ​of ‌San Lázaro ​at ‌El ‌Rincón outside ​Havana, ​where ​crutches, candles, ​and ‌ex-votos ‌accumulate each ​December.[3]

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
  2. Hopkins, Princes and Peasants: Smallpox in History, University of Chicago Press, 1983.
  3. Murphy, Santería: An African Religion in America, Beacon Press, 1988. ↗
11

Scholarly Sources

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Cited primary and secondary sources with full bibliographic metadata.

The ​account of ‌Ọbalúayé given ‌in this ​edition rests ​on the ​witnesses and ​reference works ​listed ‌below. Idowu's ​monograph treats ​the smallpox ‌power within ​the Yoruba ‌pantheon; the ​ethnographies document ‌his ​cult in ​West Africa ​and across ​the Atlantic.

  • ​[1] Idowu, ‌E. Bolaji, ​Olódùmarè: God ‌in ​Yoruba Belief, ‌Longmans, 1962 ​— the ‌standard study ​of the ‌Yoruba pantheon, ​including the ​smallpox ‌power and ‌his euphemistic ‌names. Full ​text
  • [2] ​Bascom, William, ‌Ifa Divination: ​Communication Between ​Gods ‌and Men ​in West ​Africa, Indiana ‌University Press, ​1969 — ‌field documentation ​of the ​divination ​corpus that ​prescribes his ‌propitiation. Full ‌text
  • [3] ​Mason, John, ‌Four New ​World Yoruba ​Rituals, ‌Yoruba Theological ‌Archministry — ‌diaspora ritual ‌practice.
  • [4] ​Verger, Pierre, ‌Notes sur ​le Culte ​des ​Orisa et ‌Vodun, IFAN, ​Dakar, 1957 ​— classic ​ethnography of ‌orisha cults ​in West ​Africa ​and Bahia.
  • ‌[5] Murphy, ​Joseph M., ‌Santería: An ​African Religion ‌in America, ​Beacon Press, ‌1988 ‌— the ​standard study ​of Babalú ​Ayé's Cuban ​cult and ‌its Catholic ‌veil. Full ​text

Sources

  1. Idowu, E. Bolaji, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief, Longmans, 1962. ↗
  2. Bascom, William, Ifa Divination: Communication Between Gods and Men in West Africa, Indiana University Press, 1969. ↗
  3. Mason, John, Four New World Yoruba Rituals, Yoruba Theological Archministry.
  4. Verger, Pierre, Notes sur le Culte des Orisa et Vodun, IFAN, Dakar, 1957.
  5. Murphy, Joseph M., Santería: An African Religion in America, Beacon Press, 1988. ↗
12

Ifá Corpus

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

The ​Ifá ‌corpus knows ‌him ​under ​his ​dangerous ​older names ​— ‌Ṣọ̀pọ̀nná, ​the ​smallpox ‌power one ​does ‌not ​name ‌lightly ​in the ​dry ​season ​— ​and ‌prescribes his ​propitiation ‌when ​the ‌odù ​warn of ‌epidemic, ​skin ‌affliction, ​or ​the anger ‌of ‌the ‌earth. ​The ​verses treat ‌him ​with ​a ‌grammar ​of respectful ​distance: ‌euphemism, ​redirection, ‌prompt sacrifice. ​He ​is ​also ​proof ‌that Ifá's ‌logic ​is ‌reciprocal ​— ​the power ‌that ‌sends ‌the ‌pox ​is the ‌power ​that ​lifts ​it, ‌and the ​verses ​addressing ​him ‌move ​within a ​single ​breath ‌from ​appeasement ‌to petition ​for ‌cure. ​Babalawos ‌learned ‌his herbs, ​the ​tradition ​says, ​because ‌his diseases ‌taught ​them.[1][2]

Sources

  1. Bascom, Ifa Divination.
  2. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
13

Oral Tradition

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

His ​oríkì are ‌built ‌on euphemism, ​and ​that is ​their ​fascination. Rather ​than ‌speak the ​pox-name ​Ṣọ̀pọ̀nná in ‌the season ​when ‌his power ​walks ‌abroad, singers ​use ​honourifics — ​Láàlú ​among them ​— ‌and the ​kingship ‌title Ọbalúayé ​itself: ‌praise that ​protects ‌by refusing ​to ‌describe. The ​poetry ​praises the ‌dog that ‌finds ‌the herb, ​the ​crutch that ‌still ​travels, the ​body ‌that survives ​its ​own ruin. ‌In ​diaspora houses ‌his ​litanies are ​sung ​in low ​voices ‌at twilight ‌with ​the lights ‌reduced ​— praise ​offered the ‌way ‌one praises ‌a ‌storm: respectfully, ​and ‌from a ​doorway.[1][2] ​In Cuba ​the ‌praise becomes ​pilgrimage: ​each 17 ​December, ‌devotees sing ​promises ​— promesas ​— ‌to Babalú ​Ayé ‌in his ​guise as ‌San ​Lázaro and ‌pay ‌them at ​El ​Rincón, some ​crawling ​the last ‌kilometres ‌on their ​knees.[3]

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
  2. Mason, Four New World Yoruba Rituals.
  3. Murphy, Santería: African Spirits in America.
14

Diaspora Traditions

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Nowhere ​is ‌his diaspora ‌story ​more ​dramatic ​than in ​Cuba, ​where ‌Babalú ​Ayé became ​San ‌Lázaro ​— ‌the sore-covered ​beggar ‌of ​the ​Gospel parable ​— ​and ​where ‌every 17 ​December ‌tens ​of ‌thousands crawl, ​limp, ‌or ​drag ‌stones on ​pilgrimage ​to ‌the ‌shrine of ‌El ​Rincón ​outside ‌Havana, among ​the ​largest ‌Afro-Catholic ​processions on ​earth. ‌In ​Brazil ‌he is ​Obaluaiê ​or ​Omolu, ​syncretised with ‌São ‌Lázaro ​and ‌São Roque, ​his ​ceremonies ‌conducted ‌in near-darkness. ‌The ‌era ​of ‌HIV gave ​his ​cult ​renewed ‌gravity: the ​orisha ​of ​epidemic ‌and cure ​became ​patron ​of ‌those the ​modern ‌plague ​had ‌marked. Crutches, ​burlap, ‌dogs, ‌and ​dry wine ​— ​the ​iconography ‌crossed the ‌ocean ​whole.[1][2]

Sources

  1. Murphy, Santería: African Spirits in America.
  2. Mason, Four New World Yoruba Rituals.
15

Meditation & Reflection

Contributed by PuniCodex Team

Contemplative or interpretive essay on the figure's enduring meaning.

Ọbalúayé ​is ‌the god ‌nobody ​wants ​until they ​need ​him. ​He is ‌smallpox ​scars, ​crutches, ‌the cough ​that ‌will ​not stop, ‌the ​fever ​that ​empties the ​world. ​And ‌yet he ​is ‌also ​the one ‌who ​knows ‌the ​herb, the ‌cool ​stream, ​the moment ‌when ‌the ‌crisis ​turns.

To ​approach ‌him ​is to ​accept ‌the ​fragility of ​the ‌body. ​He ‌does not ​promise ​that ​illness is ​meaningful, ‌only ‌that it ​is ‌real ​and ​that survival ‌is ‌possible. ‌In a ‌culture ​that ‌often ​hides disability ​and ​death, ‌Ọbalúayé stands ​at ​the ​crossroads in ‌sackcloth, ​leaning ​on ​crutches, accompanied ‌by ​dogs. ‌He makes ​poverty ‌and ​sickness ‌visible — ‌and ​in ​making them ​visible, ​he ‌begins to ‌heal ​them.[1]

Sources

  1. Idowu, Olódùmarè: God in Yoruba Belief.
16

Edit History

Live Record

Immutable revision timeline and attribution.

Every approved change will appear here with a timestamp, diff, and credit to the contributing university and student.

17

Attribution

Live Record

Universities and students credited for contributions.

Verified universities and their students will be credited here as the Scholarly Edition grows.